| | Team - Cup Win by Year |
| | year | | tm_nm | tm_abr | manager |
| | 2007 | | East Bay Avalanche | EB | Ryan Ashburn |
| | 2006 | | St. Paul Polar Bears | SP | Rick Ohman |
| | 2005 | | Texas Rattlers | TR | James Powell |
| | 2004 | | Pontiac Panthers | PP | David Neinken |
| | 2003 | | Bodega Bay Ballbreakers | BB | Manny Delao |
| | 2002 | | Bodega Bay Ballbreakers | BB | Manny Delao |
| | 2001 | | Pontiac Panthers | PP | David Neinken |
| | 2000 | | California Quakes | CQ | Steve Wolfenberger |
| | 1999 | | Long Island Rockies | LI | Eddie Masone |
| | 1998 | | Tri-Valley Tigers | TV | Myron DeVoto |
| | 1997 | | California Quakes | CQ | Steve Wolfenberger |
| | 1996 | | Pontiac Panthers | PP | David Neinken |
| | 1995 | | California Quakes | CQ | Steve Wolfenberger |
| | 1994 | | Northside Rockers | NR | Alan Brostoff |
| | 1993 | | Bayside Barracudas | BB | Mike McNeil |
| | 1992 | | New York Giants | NY | Jerry Conca |
| | 1991 | | California Quakes | CQ | Steve Wolfenberger |
| | 1990 | | Pleasanton Valley Falcons | PV | Ryan Ashburn |
| | 1989 | | Sillicon Valley Chipmonks | SV | Clyde Jones |
| | 1988 | | New Hanover Nighthawks | NH | Jake Smith |
| | 1987 | | Oshkosh Indians | OI | Scott Williams |
| | 1985 | | Tallahasse Bombers | TB | Johnnie Bowman |
| | 1984 | | Windmill Gap Buccaneers | WG | Tony Hodges |
| | Tuesday, January 08, 2008 | Page 1 of 1 |