| RBC | SBC | Totals | ||||||||||
| Player | Team | Pts | Player | Team | Pts | Team | # | |||||
| C | Team | Pts | C | Team | Pts | SAC | 4 | |||||
| Joe | MAUER | RAT | 11 | Geovany | SOTO | DIL | 10 | CHE | 0 | |||
| Chris | IANNETTA | PAP | 11 | Brandon | INGE | BCE | 8 | TAM | 7 | |||
| WLA | 1 | |||||||||||
| 1B | Team | Pts | 1B | Team | Pts | NYK | 5 | |||||
| Mark | TEIXEIRA | SPD | 11 | Albert | PUJOLS | WLA | 10 | PAP | 9 | |||
| Kevin | YOUKILIS | PAP | 8 | Lance | BERKMAN | BCE | 9 | RAT | 5 | |||
| Joey | VOTTO | RAT | 8 | Adam | La ROCHE | TAM | 9 | FLO | 4 | |||
| SPD | 4 | |||||||||||
| 2B | Team | Pts | 2B | Team | Pts | PRR | 1 | |||||
| Dustin | PEDROIA | PAP | 11 | Mark | DeROSA | FLO | 10 | CLE | 0 | |||
| Placido | POLANCO | RAT | 8 | Dan | UGGLA | TAM | 10 | BCE | 3 | |||
| MIS | 0 | |||||||||||
| 3B | Team | Pts | 3B | Team | Pts | PHI | 3 | |||||
| Aramis | RAMIREZ | PHI | 13 | Alex | RODRIGUEZ | SAC | 12 | SEA | 0 | |||
| Melvin | MORA | RAT | 9 | Troy | GLAUS | TAM | 12 | FWG | 3 | |||
| SS | Team | Pts | SS | Team | Pts | |||||||
| Stephen | DREW | NYK | 10 | Hanley | RAMIREZ | FWG | 12 | |||||
| Cristian | GUZMAN | PHI | 10 | Orlando | CABRERA | DIL | 9 | |||||
| Marco | SCUTARO | TAM | 9 | |||||||||
| OF | Team | Pts | ||||||||||
| Nick | MARKAKIS | PAP | 12 | OF | Team | Pts | ||||||
| Magglio | ORDONEZ | PHI | 12 | Ryan | LUDWICK | FLO | 15 | |||||
| Vernon | WELLS | NYK | 11 | Carlos | BELTRAN | FLO | 12 | |||||
| Brad | HAWPE | PAP | 10 | Matt | HOLLIDAY | FWG | 10 | |||||
| Jason | BAY | RAT | 10 | |||||||||
| DH | Team | Pts | ||||||||||
| DH | Team | Pts | Manny | RAMIREZ | TAM | 11 | ||||||
| Jhonny | PERALTA | SPD | 10 | Vladimir | GUERRERO | SAC | 10 | |||||
| SP | Team | Pts | SP | Team | Pts | |||||||
| Johan | SANTANA | NYK | 38 | Mike | MUSSINA | ETB | 29 | |||||
| Brandon | WEBB | SPD | 29 | Edinson | VOLQUEZ | FLO | 23 | |||||
| Justin | DUCHSCHERER | PAP | 28 | Jon | LESTER | DIL | 22 | |||||
| Cliff | LEE | PAP | 28 | Zack | GREINKE | SAC | 21 | |||||
| Roy | HALLADAY | PAP | 25 | Daisuke | MATSUZAKA | TAM | 20 | |||||
| C.C. | SABATHIA | PRR | 24 | |||||||||
| RP | Team | Pts | ||||||||||
| RP | Team | Pts | Jose | ARREDONDO | TAM | 22 | ||||||
| Grant | BALFOUR | NYK | 19 | Mariano | RIVERA | FWG | 19 | |||||
| Joey | DEVINE | NYK | 18 | Taylor | BUCHHOLZ | SAC | 18 | |||||
| Brad | ZIEGLER | PAP | 17 | Joe | NELSON | BCE | 16 | |||||
| Joe | NATHAN | SPD | 17 | Brad | LIDGE | ETB | 15 | |||||